The Emotional Weight of ‘I Have To’: Letting Go of the Psychology of Survival
- Elmira Arthur

- Oct 11
- 4 min read

This meditation was not a vision of someone else. It was a mirror — a portrait of what happens when the human spirit spends too long surviving instead of living.
The mine was not hell. It was an ordinary life, lived without awareness.
Endless work. Enduring. Trying to be good enough. Hoping that obedience might earn mercy. Giving will earn love. The man’s chains were not made of iron — they were made of “I have to.” I have to keep going. I have to earn. I have to prove. I have no choice.
That’s how most people live. Not because they are blind or weak, but because they’ve forgotten that freedom is an option. When you’re born underground, even the dark starts to feel like home.
When Endurance Becomes Identity: Letting Go of the Emotional Weight Behind the Psychology of Survival
What moved me the most was not John’s pain, but his loyalty to it. He believed the shaft was the only place where he had any control — that his suffering was safer than the unknown. Watching him, I understood something about how suffering maintains itself.
Pain doesn’t always come from violence; sometimes it comes from loyalty — to systems, to roles, to identities that once kept us alive. We don’t realize how much of what we call “character” is simply what endurance has made of us.
He found brief comfort in small discoveries — a flash of ore, a glimmer of approval. He called it happiness. He was proud of surviving another day. Those moments were his proof that life still existed somewhere, even if he could never keep it.
Every time the guards took the metal from his hands, he accepted it, because that’s what he had learned to do: give everything away and call it survival. We all do this. We cling to moments of half-light because we fear the full brightness might destroy us.
The Awakening Within the Ruins: Where Collapse Becomes Clarity
When the shaft collapsed, something real finally happened. Everything he depended on — his routines, his discipline, his self-control — failed. He could no longer dig, no longer obey. And in that stillness — under the rubble — he felt a strange relief. The body may break, but the truth slips through the cracks. That moment of collapse is the point where control ends and consciousness begins.
Then came the regret — that quiet, merciless awareness that he had never truly lived. Regret not for dying, but for never having known what life was outside the mine. That kind of regret doesn’t destroy you; it tells the truth you’ve avoided for years. That regret is what wakes the soul. Not shame, not punishment — just that deep ache of I missed my own life.
When Choice Returns: The Slow Path from Survival to Living
When I met him in that space, it was not as a savior, but as a witness-someone who recognized the look of a person who has forgotten the sky. You can’t convince someone like that to hope. You can only sit with them in the dark until they begin to remember what light feels like.
So I told him about the sky — not to inspire him, but to reintroduce him to something real. He didn’t believe me at first. That’s how hopelessness works: it mistakes imagination for cruelty.
But when I asked, “If you had a choice, what would you do?” — there was a pause. That pause was everything. He said he’d want to live. That one sentence cracked open the whole mine. The human heart is not healed by explanations; it’s healed by the return of wanting — by the right to desire life again.
Lifting him out wasn’t easy. Healing never is. It’s not a clean story. There’s blood, shame, resistance. He wanted to give up more than once. But something small — stubborn — kept him reaching toward the air. Recovery is rarely about miracles; it’s the slow education of the nervous system in safety.
The Hands That Once Dug Now Build in Freedom. Living Beyond What Kept You Bound
Eventually, he built something new — a different way to mine, one that didn’t destroy the earth or the men who worked it. It was his way of making peace with what once enslaved him. He hadn’t escaped the mine; he had redefined its meaning.
The same hands that once dug for survival now created out of freedom.
Years later, he stood on a balcony, looking at the smoke rising from the old industrial towers. He didn’t flinch or turn away, didn’t feel anger or nostalgia. Just a quiet understanding: That was me once. I lived there. And now I don’t.
I think about that often — the quiet dignity of a person who has nothing left to prove. He doesn’t need to forgive the past or erase it. He just doesn’t belong to it anymore.
That’s what healing really is — not forgiveness, not enlightenment, but the ability to look at the past without wanting to return or run away.
The mine still exists in the world. So do the guards. But the man who once labored there has seen the sky. That is the difference between endurance and freedom: one keeps you alive; the other lets you live.
This vision reminded me that awakening is never dramatic. It is the softest thing — the moment you realize the world above ground has been waiting for you all along. You don’t need to believe in transcendence to understand that. You only need to have survived something long enough to know what it costs to keep digging when the sky is calling your name.
When endurance has shaped too much of who you are, freedom feels foreign.
But it isn’t. It’s a forgotten language your soul still remembers.
Let’s help you remember.


